Thursday, October 4, 2012

Let The Debate Continue

In the days and weeks to come much will be said about last night's debate. Winners and losers will be proclaimed; sound bites dissected and analyzed to death. Facial expressions and body language will be hashed and rehashed. And in the interest of keeping pundits and talking heads employed, I'm okay with all of it. But to anyone actually paying attention last night, some very interesting and perhaps disturbing things were said by Gov. Romney.

First, despite his stylistic performance (which by most accounts caused him to "win" the debate) there was very little in the way of substance. However, that which was substantive about his arguments is cause for great concern if not all out panic. Despite what some would call a lackluster performance, President Obama was able to pin Gov. Romney down on two very critical issues: Medicare and Social Security.

As it relates to Medicare, Gov Romney was forced to concede that his plan would turn it into a voucher system which will inevitably leave many seniors facing increased costs in order to keep the same level of coverage. The idea of introducing competition into the Medicare discussion sounds intriguing until you realize that any private company's bottom line is increased profits. Some argue that competition brings prices down while simultaneously raising the quality of services and products offered. In a perfect world, that may be true but ours is not a perfect world. The world we live in is imperfect and filled with competition that neither lowers costs nor raises quality. If the merits of the competition argument are true, then how do you account for runaway gas prices? There's plenty of competition in the petroleum market, yet prices have skyrocketed in recent years. Food and utility costs are out of control as well yet there is plenty of competition in both agriculture and utility markets. 

The bottom line, is that there are explanations to those questions/realities and depending on your political/philosophical leanings, your explanation may be different than mine. That's not important. What is important is that regardless of how you account for it, there are forces continuously exerting  pressure on "free" markets that drive costs, quality and availability. The cyclical nature of "free" markets means that peaks and valleys are inevitable and that as surely as there will be times of prosperity there will also be times of difficulty. So the question you need to ask yourself is this: "If my healthcare coverage (and social security if Romney has his way) is subject to the ebbs and flows of the market, will I be able to survive the inevitable downturn when it comes?"  

It's been four years since the housing bubble burst. Many homeowners have still not recovered their lost equity. And those are the fortunate homeowners because many lost their homes altogether. Now some will suggest that the bursting bubble is the market's way of self-correcting. Perhaps. But if we subject healthcare and social security to the same free market system and free market forces that drove many to lose their homes and put many more upside down in their mortgages, what's going to happen to the level and quality of people's lives medically under the same market conditions and forces? Can anyone afford to be "upside down" in healthcare or social security?  Can we survive a "necessary" market correction when it's our healthcare or life savings that are on the line? Do we want to use our health and life savings as a social experiment? Maybe Romney & Ryan are right, but what if they're not? What if our healthcare and social security suffer the same fate as our houses and our 401 k's have suffered and in fact are still suffering? It's a pretty risky gamble just to prove a political point. 

Another critical point revealed last night is something Gov. Romney went out of his way to emphasize. In response to a question about the difference between the healthcare plan he instituted in Massachusetts as Governor and the President's Affordable Care Act, he could not deny that his state plan served as the blueprint for the national plan. What he did say however, was that he intended it to be a blueprint, not for the federal government, but for individual states. So, in other words, he wants states to have the ability and freedom to choose their own path. Last night, Mitt Romney reintroduced the state's rights argument into the national discussion. 

Personally, I get nervous whenever I hear anyone advocating for state's rights because the state's rights argument was used when southern states wanted to keep the federal government out of their decision about whether to abolish slavery. That decision, they argued, should have been left in the hands of the governors and state legislatures and the federal government should have kept their noses out of the state's business. 

The same argument was used during the Civil Right's Movement when critical decisions were being made about desegregation and voting rights and the good news is that in each of those cases the federal government did not concede the point and history has proven those to be very good decisions that went against individual state's wishes/rights.

History gives me enough reason to be concerned about granting states the right to choose their own path regarding healthcare. But practicality gives me pause as well. Let's assume for a moment that Gov. Romney gets his wish. States would then be able to determine the type of plan they institute, or even if they're going to offer a plan at all. So what happens to you if you live in a state where the governor and state legislators decide not to put any plan in place and leave you on your own to find coverage? 49 Governors, like Mitt Romney, could decide to put some type of plan in place but you could wind up in the 1 state out of 50 where there is no coverage or plan. What happens to you then? Do you pack up and move to one of the other 49 states? Do you simply live without coverage? Or do you pay three or four times as much as those who live in neighboring states for the same coverage because you've been forced to acquire it on your own? 

Just because one state offers coverage doesn't mean the other states will follow suit. If that were necessarily true we wouldn't have even had a discussion about the Affordable Care Act because the other 49 states would have followed the shining example of Gov. Romney and the state of Massachusetts in adopting their own statewide healthcare plans. 

Since that's not what happened however, I'm forced to wonder what magical event will transpire that will cause each individual governor and each individual state legislature to suddenly come up with a reasonable plan. It hasn't happened yet, despite Massachusetts paving the way so what's going to cause it to happen now? And more importantly, what safeguards are going to be put in place to make sure that everyone has access and who's going to enforce those safeguards? These and other detailed specifics are what people have been asking Gov. Romney to provide for months now, and despite his strong stylistic performance last night, are still noticeably absent from his campaign. 

On a related side note, much has been made by the Right during this campaign about the size and role of government. According to them government is out of control, overreaching and too intrusive. But the reality is that if the Right gets it's way, if some authority is stripped from the federal government and given to the states, it won't do anything to control either the size or reach of government. All it will do is shift the "fat" from the federal to state level. So instead of "bloated" federal government we'll have "bloated" state government. Instead of increased federal taxes we'll have increased state taxes but the net effect will be the same. So the argument here really isn't about the size or reach of government, it's about which form of government has the locus of power. 

The Affordable Care Act, Medicare, Social Security. These programs, while not perfect by any stretch of the imagination, provide a guarantee that people who worked their entire lives and paid into the system will be able to collect on their investment when the time comes. It's a federal guarantee and as such, is granted to everyone. They are not entitlements. They are not handouts. They are earned benefits that cannot be stripped away at the whim of a governor or state legislature. And for that I am thankful. 

Taking care of an elderly parent has reinforced my personal resolve to make sure those benefits are protected and I have no interest in letting the governor of my state decide the fate of my mother's health. Nor am I interested in rolling the dice with my mother's health care or social security in a market that has undergone 6-7 downturns of varying degrees in my lifetime. I personally, cannot afford a Mitt Romney Presidency and am very concerned about the possibility of our nation being run like a corporation by a man who sees things through the prism of profits and "acceptable" losses; who is perfectly comfortable with writing off the companies he helped close during his time at Bain Captial, as necessary market adjustments; expendable cogs in the capitalist wheel. 

We got a glimpse last night at what he believes to be expendable elements of our national fabric; from Medicare to Sesame Street and I think Big Bird, Bert & Ernie, Mr. Snuffleupagus,  and the Cookie Monster would agree with me that a Mitt Romney Presidency would come at too great a risk and too high a cost. 









Thursday, November 10, 2011

More reflections from Penn State

The more this story develops the more I'm appalled. In a CNN article chronicling the recent campus events the writer says "in some ways the campus is divided. Some still mourn the loss of the almost godlike coach they have grown to love. Others are struggling with the heinous allegations." That one line sums up what's wrong with this situation. I understand loyalty and love and supoort. Those qualities and characteristics are admirable. But what the legions of fans fail to understand is that this is so much bigger than a career, a program or a legacy. Children were abused on your campus people! They were abused by a man who for decades was entrusred to shape and mold the lives of young men. As soon as it came to light, everyone who knew about it should have risked everything to stop it and prevent it from happening again. Those children needed an advocate, they needed protection and they got neither.

Conversation has now shifted to the game this weekend and where Penn State goes from here. Players have said they're going to play for Coach Paterno on Saturday.Students act like they don't know what to do. Here's an idea. You want to know where to go from here? Go to class. Get the education you went to Penn State to receive and pray for the victims of the abuse and their families. I understand the players playing for their ousted coach. It's understandable given the relationship they have with him but who's playing for the victims? Who are their advocates in this? All I've heard today is talk of what's best for Penn State and it's representatives. What about what's best for the victims? Who's looking out for them and busting their humps to make sure their best interests are served? On Saturday afternoon there will probably be a football game in College Station and some people will see that game as some sort of rallying, unifying event for the Penn State University and community. I don't really care if they play the game or not but I hope that at some point in the very near future, somebody will ask the victims what they want; that somebody will even ask the question of what's best for them.

With Great Power Comes Great Responsibility

The last 72+ hours have turned the college football world on it's head. In the wake of the unfolding revelations regarding the child abuse scandal at Penn State University many opinions have been expressed and people are as divided on this issue as they are on almost everything else. It still amazes me how a single issue can generate so much heated division but that's an issue for another day.

The bottom line regarding this particular issue is that Joe Paterno, for all of his accomplishments, successes, and victories, failed when it mattered most. I know people are outraged about his fate because he was not directly responsible for abusing those children. "It's not like he's the one who raped them" they'll say. And they are correct. He was not the one in the shower with the 10 year old boy. He did not use his influence and power to prey upon young children. But all of those things happened on his watch. And when he found out about it, he fulfilled his legal obligation by telling his boss. But in a case like this, where children's lives are involved, where safety, trust and innocence were so thoroughly violated and broken, Joe Paterno had more than a legal obligation. Joe Paterno was morally bound to verify the report when it was brought to him. He was morally obligated to put a stop to it when he discovered it and he was morally obligated to report it to the authorities and bring it to light as quickly and openly as possible. He covered his a$$ by telling his boss but he should have done more. He admitted as much when he finally spoke yesterday informing the world that he would so graciously retire at the end of the season.

For all those people who are rioting on campus and voicing their outrage over Paterno's firing, I have one question for you. What if it was your son, brother, nephew, cousin or friend who had been abused? I know the answer to that question already and so do you. The abuse and the way it was handled are bad enough. What's worse is that people are blindly protesting for and defending a man who is not worthy of such outrage. These protests are not about fairness or right and wrong, they're about football. The campus rioters are defending the athletic tradition of the Penn State football program; nothing more. If this was truly about fairness and protesting injustice, then why are there no protesters outside the home and office of the fired university president? Why aren't they chanting his name like mindless sheep? I'm guessing that most of them don't even know the president's name, let alone care that he too was fired over this scandal.

Sports has often caused fans to elevate those who achieve great success. Athletes and coaches in some cases, often get slaps on the wrist for crimes the rest of us would do significant time for. But in this case, I'm glad the board of trustees at Penn State had enough guts to do what they did. But let's be clear, the firing of Joe Paterno and University President Graham Spainier are both C.Y.A. moves by the University. They're doing what they can to minimize the impact of the litigation that's sure to come. But even if it's for the wrong reasons, they did the right thing.

The lives of children are more important than football legacies, championships and reputations. Joe Paterno did a lot of good over the course of the 46 years he served as head football coach at Penn State University. He was arguably the biggest icon in college football and certainly the biggest icon at Penn State. But with iconic status comes iconic responsibility. To whom much is given, much is required and when faced with the greatest challenge of his career, he was not legendary; he wasn't iconic. He was a man who did much less than he should have to stop and rectify abuse that happened on his watch. He's fortunate that the only thing he lost was his job. The children that his assistant coach abused have lost much much more than that. If Joe Paterno had put as much effort and energy into defending those children as his legions of fans are exerting to protest his firing then perhaps more abuse could have been prevented. Better yet, if the protesters themselves devoted as much energy and outrage to defending the abused as they are in defending their beloved coach, then maybe the victims road to recovery might be less bumpy.

Monday, March 2, 2009

Are Republicans Shooting Themselves in the Foot?

Now that President Obama's stimulus package has been signed into law, the budget is next. Despite his efforts to achieve bipartisan cooperation, Republicans seem unwilling and unable to get into the same book, let alone the same page concerning how best to pull this country's economy out of the ditch. The fact that, for the most part, these same Republicans presided over the economic collapse is a bit ironic at best and downright hypocritical at worst.

Case in point: Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal. Here's a man who was more than happy to accept federal money to help rebuild his state in the aftermath of two hurricanes: Katrina and Gustav. When offered federal money again through the new stimulus however, he made a very public spectacle, refusing the money and using it as an opportunity to play tyipical political games; putting partisan political gamesmanship over the needs of his constituents. Money that could be used to imporve Louisiana's devastated infrastructure or extend the unemployment benefits of the hundreds of thousands Louisianans who've lost their jobs is being offered and at least publicly refused by Jindal and other Republican governors.

The hypocrisy is what's most appalling. Standing on a soapbox of fiscal responsibility, we've received lectures and rants from Republican leaders about the spending spree of the new administration. Coming from the very folk who presided over an adminstration that nearly doubled the national debt from $5.7 Trilliilon to over $10 Trillion in eight years is a little tough to take seriously.

And the party itself is becoming increasingly difficult to take seriously. From Gov. Palin to Gov. Jindal to the always amusing Michael Steele, the party seems to be grasping at any and all straws as it sees itself slipping into irrelevance. Perhaps the grandstanding and opposition to all things Obama can be seen as a desperate attempt to remain relevant. What appears more likely however, is that we are witnessing a ridiculous, large scale case of sour grapes.

The fact is, America voted against this type of politics in November. At all levels, the majority of Americans seem to be tired of the typical gamesmanship that has made Washington (in)famous. By playing these types of games, the GOP is truly doing itself a disservice. Which, for the record, is fine by me since I was part of the revolution to get as many of them out of office as possible. It's not enough to be anti-liberal or anti-democrat or even anti-Obama (particularly since his apporval rating is off the charts at the moment). You have to "for" something and right now nobody, including most Republicans, seems to know what it is they stand for. What are the priciples by which the party stands? What is their foundation? After eight years of Bush-o-nomics it sure isn't fiscal responsibility. So please spare us the lectures, soapboxes, and public displays of indignation and start getting to the task of pulling the nation out of this recession. It may already be too late but at least by exhibiting even a semblance of a cooperative spirit, you might actually be able to hold onto some of your positions in upcoming elections; and if not your positions, then perhaps a shred or two of your dignity.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

A Dream Fulfilled?

As I watched coverage of this unprecedented inaugural event I heard many pundits reflecting on the significance of now President Obama's achievement juxtaposed with Dr. King's legacy and what it all means. Many suggest that Obama's assent to the highest office in the land signifies the fulfillment Dr. King's "dream. " Others make the case that there is yet more work to be done before we can claim "mission accomplished." I find myself in the camp of those who express the latter sentiment. Dr. King's vision for this nation was not limited to winning political office, although it is an important step. His dream was that America would advance to a place where differences; whether racial, gender, or class, would be recognized and appreciated, but where ultimately, they would have no bearing on people's ability to achieve their own individual dreams.

It is in regard to issues of class where I am least ready to proclaim King's dream fulfilled. Racially, we have come a long way in America. Barriers are being shattered every day and today's events are proof of just how far we have advanced. But a careful examination of the President's resume' shows an education gained both within the walls of institutions of higher learning and outside those walls, that the average American will never achieve. Columbia University and Harvard Law are only accessible to a very select few and the political circles he has navigated for the last 20 years are even more exclusive.

While there is little doubt that President Obama is supremely qualified and competent to be President, it is equally obvious that there is an ever widening gap between people at opposite ends of the socio-economic specturm in this country.

Some may counter my argument by pointing to Obama's modest upbringing in a single parent home and laud the fact that he pulled himself up by his own boot-straps and made a way for himself despite tough circumstances. And they would have a valid point. I guess I would respond to that by saying that you cannot point to the exception and attmept to make it the norm. Put another way; for every one Barack Obama there are thousands of others in similar situations who live a drastically different reality. There are tens, if not hundreds of thousands of people who apply to the likes Columbia and Harvard every year and the vast majority of them are denied.

There are millions of people in the supposed wealthiest nation in the world, who still live without healthcare. Millions unemployed. Millions living below the poverty line. Millions of children who don't get proper nourishment. Millions being edcuated (or mis-educated as it were) in schools that are under-funded. And the list of economic disparites goes on and on and on.

There is a ruling class in this country; it's not based on bloodlines or birthrights, but it is steeped in wealth. The door of opportunity is always open, provided you can afford to walk through it.

Nothing in business or politics occurs wihtout vast amounts of money changing hands. Somehow, the wealthiest people in America manged to CONvince our leaders to grant them even more wealth in the form of "rescue" plans and "TARPS." Meanwhile, the average American is struggling to provide even the most basic necesities as the leaders of these financial and auto manufacturing institutions land safely under the protection of golden parachutes. And the Coingressional parade of hat-in-hand executives has only just begun. The question at this point is not "how much is this going to cost the taxpayer?" but rather, "who's next?" Which industy will present their case next? Which company will come crying that the sky is falling? Which multi-millionaire executive will come begging for assistance with a repayment plan outlined on a cocktail napkin?

Unfortunately, Dr. King's dream has been watered down and romanticized and if we asses the weakened version then the case could be made that it has been fulfilled. If however, we analyzed the more nuanced, complex version of his dream and evaluate all of it's intricacies, we'll be forced to confront the reality that in many ways we have made great strides. But in others, particularly areas of classism, we have many miles to go before we sleep.

Wednesday, December 10, 2008

Thank You Letter To John McCain

It's been a little over a month since Barack Obama was elected the 44th President of the United States. The campaign was one of the ugliest I've seen in my adult life and I believe it was largely due to the campaign strategy of the McCain/Palin ticket. The following letter (which I never intend to actually send) sums up the frustration I, and many others felt during the campaign. Instead of a campaign on issues, we got the typical Karl Rove identiy/culturue war. Fortunately America was paying attention and was not hoodwinked by the politics of distraction. Barack's election was historic but it does not mean we have arrived. His presidency is not the destination, it is but one step (albeit a very significant and profound step) in the right direction. If you agree with the sentiments in this letter, say so. If you do not, say so and let's have an open, honest dialogue.


Dear Senator McCain,


Now that this historic election is over, the nation owes you a debt of gratitude and on behalf of Americans everywhere, let me be the first to say “thank you.”

• Thank you for making the same mistake Hilary Clinton made in underestimating Senator Obama. I understand what a shock it must be to have been so soundly defeated by a man who, prior to the Democratic National Convention just four years ago, was relatively unknown. Your inability to see the real challenge he posed to your bid for the White House made his ascent that much easier.

• Thank you for constantly mocking and disrespecting your opponent’s experience as a community organizer. Your campaign’s inability to adapt new strategies and techniques gave young voters only one choice in this election. Senator Obama used his oft criticized community organizing experience to build the most effective, strategic, grass-roots campaign in the history of American politics. While you were launching fearful, racist, robo calls, his “ground game” literally knocked on more than a million doors the day before the election.


• Thank you for wasting time resurrecting old news by constantly brining up his past associations. Because Senator Obama faced a real challenge during the Democratic Primary, he had been fully vetted by the time he got to the general election, so your question: “who is the Real Barack Obama?” had already been asked, re-asked and sufficiently answered. Every moment you spent talking about Ayers, Rezko, Wright and Khalidi was a moment you failed to let the nation know your plan for getting America back on track.

• Thank you for picking Sarah Palin. That decision gave us the first glimpse into your judgment as a leader. By picking someone so utterly unqualified for the position of Vice President, you not only energized the Republican base, you energized the rest of the electorate. I’m not sure whether you really believe she’s qualified (my instincts tell me you don’t) or whether she was a pawn in a desperate attempt to change the conversation and shift the momentum of the Democratic National Convention. Either way, it revealed a lot about the manner in which you would govern this country. The contrast between your erratic campaign (from the Palin pick to the fake campaign suspension to the first debate bluff) and Senator Obama’s steady, focused leadership, was stark; and it was greatly appreciated as we pondered who would be best to lead during these difficult times.

• Thank you for turning Palin loose and letting her be the “real” Sarah Palin. The two of you incited the ugliest sentiments and emotions during your rallies and as you threw racial fire-bombs and stood back to watch the carnage, America was able to confront its racist past and present; and vote for Obama anyway. Your attempts to scare us into voting for you and against him, actually accomplished the opposite, and as you said in your concession speech: “the American people have spoken and they have spoken clearly.”

There are many more reasons for us to be grateful today but I wanted to personally thank you for the role you played in making history. As a maverick, I hope we can count on you to reach across the aisle and work with President Obama as passionately and vigorously as you worked to defeat him in this election. I am confident that you will live up to your campaign slogan and put your dislike and disappointment aside and put Country first.

THANK YOU,